Forum Discussion

ColtenHood's avatar
ColtenHood
Copper Contributor
Oct 03, 2024

Microsoft engages in planned obsolescence with Windows 11

One year ago, I purchased a refurbished Dell desktop with an Intel 7th generation processor. It was originally compatible with Windows 11 22H2, but this year I encountered an issue where it could not be updated to 23H2, despite meeting the requirements like having TPM 2.0. As a result, I realized that Windows 11 22H2 would lose support by October 2024, leaving my system without security updates. To address this, I made the decision to switch back to Windows 10 to ensure I receive updates until October 2025.

 

One of the advantages of Windows 10 is its flexibility for users transitioning from Windows 7 and 8.1, which has been particularly beneficial for non-technical home users. However, many users may find themselves stuck with unsupported Windows 10 systems after the end of support, creating a barrier to staying up to date. There is a sense of skepticism that Microsoft may have a financial interest in rendering older hardware obsolete, despite their claims of environmental responsibility. This approach may lead to millions of outdated devices being discarded, as Microsoft tries to address revenue challenges caused by supporting upgradeable systems on older hardware.

 

After evaluating Linux, I believe it offers a more sustainable option for non-technical home users. My Ubuntu version is supported until 2032 and runs smoothly on a 2006 Toshiba Satellite Pro P200, providing a secure and reliable experience.

 

Microsoft's dominance in the market gives them the power to dictate terms to home users, pushing them towards complying with their policies. While Windows offers a wide range of features, many of these features may not hold much value for typical home users.

1 Reply

  • Graham-STMC's avatar
    Graham-STMC
    Steel Contributor
    The original expectation of Windows 11 was that it was mostly compatible with 8th Generation Intel processors, but in testing some older models (6th and 7th generation) were compatible. Ubuntu and other Linux distros are great for tech enthusiasts but generally Windows still offers one of the most flexible operating systems that is flexible and backwards compatible for at least five years. I wouldn't expect anyone using a machine that is 18 years old to be running it effectively on Windows which evolves and changes as a service approximately twice annually. It makes no commercial sense to continuously support older hardware - Google and Apple don't so why should Microsoft? Enjoy Ubuntu if it suits you, it probably won't suit the majority of users.

Resources