I have conditional formatting formula is not working. I help with it.

hmm, I know I attached it the 2nd time.  I'm thinking the system is filtering it out.  If I recall correctly it is a .xlsm (has macros) and that might be the issue.  When I get home tonight, I will try to remember to do a 'save as' into .xlsx and see if that works.  

That said, the formula is literally what I posted above but with "*" instead of "p" because that old file used "*" instead:

=ISNUMBER(XMATCH("*", A3:C3))*(SUM(C3:E3)>SUM($E3,$I3)/2)

and the applied to range is:

C3:I18

as an explanation I used the floating range A3:C3 in the XMATCH to highlight the pick cell AND the 2 cells to the right of the picked cell IF the score in that group is > than 1/2 the sum of the 2 scores on that line

alternatively you could do a more literal formula like:

=($C3="*")*($E3>$I3)*(COLUMN(C3)<6)+($G3="*")*($E3<$I3)*(COLUMN(C3)>6)

or go back to the old way you had and break each color into 2 separate formulas

=($C3="*")*($E3>$I3)  for the left 1/2    and    =($G3="*")*($E3>$I3)  for the right 1/2