Drop Down List formula based on data in a different cell

I wrote a formula for a drop down list based on the data of another cell (see below). What am I missing?

The drop down list should be the percentages if the data in another cell is a specific result.

=IFS(P4=“Meets Expectations”,“2.75,3.00,3.25”,P4=“Above Expectations”,“3.50,3.75,4.00”,P4=“Exceptional”, “4.25,4.50,4.75”,P4=“Needs Improvement”,“1.00,1.50,2.00”,P4=“Below Expectations”,“0.00”,P4=“New Hire”,“0.00”)