Forum Discussion
Seeming memory leak in Win 11
Hello,
For the past couple months I have been experiencing a weird issue on my windows machine. Usually around 8 or so hours after a clean reboot, task manager will start reporting 170+GB of 190GB of RAM is in use when the system is basically idle. However, when I tally the entire list of processes I can only account for 4GB in use. When I use RAMMap its the same story, I can account for 4GB and it appears windows has simply misplaced a 150GB of memory. The only other symptom I notice is when I shutdown, the shutdown process will take 40+ minutes sometimes as if some process is refusing to die. This does not occur when I shutdown while memory usage appears normal.
So far I have tried:
Using different web browsers and uninstalling the one I had been using.
Removing pretty much every piece of software I have been using while the issue occurred.
Ensured windows, firmware and drivers were properly updated.
6 Replies
- Fork90Copper Contributor
This is not intend to be posted, but rather a question for the mods. Why are my replies never posting? I have replied to Jim twice now and neither have been accepted, one after 24 hours and one after almost 12.
Given how many times I have received proxy errors / 502s while refreshing this forum maybe the replies got lost, but I have my doubts. I'm more likely to assume that me asking for evidence that the shutdown issue was a different problem was seen as rude. I'm sorry, but if you're going to let someone with zero accepted answers make a wild assertion with zero evidence, you had better be prepared to let someone demand evidence.
- Neil-D13Copper Contributor
Have you ran a full AV scan and used Malwarebytes?
- Fork90Copper Contributor
I've generally not had need for an AV beyond defender since 8, but I did give it a fair try with their free trial. The only things it classified as "potentially unwanted" was a perfectly legitimate torrenting program used for OSS ISOs. Zero malware results.
- Jim ButtsCopper Contributor
Windows usually doesn't lose RAM can you post in use, available, committed , cached and paged pool numbers? The shutdown issue is a different problem.
- Fork90Copper Contributor
It took a while for the issue to resurface for me to get some hard numbers. Around 9:25PM I woke my computer from sleep mode and a few minutes after waking it I realized my ram usage was rising linearly in task manager. I can't remember for certain if this has always started after a wakeup, but I will try to keep track from now on. Over the past hour I have went from 22gb in use to 139gb in use. During this time the only process showing over 1GB of memory in use was firefox at 1.8gb roughly and every process together accounted for right at 5033MB.
Here is a table of the requested stats over the past hour. Pardon the rough formatting, tabs apparently vex this forum.In Use Compressed Committed Cached Paged pool Non-paged pool 44 81.5MB 48/202 1.6 21.1 3.8 50.5 78.3MB 55/202 1.9 26.6 4.5 73.9 39.5MB 78/202 2.1 47.1 7.1 103 46.8MB 107/202 2.3 72.3 10.3 109 46.8MB 118/202 6.4 81.6 11.5 141 1.1GB 150/202 14.3 110 15.0 139 1.1GB 148/202 14.3 108 14.8Can you explain how you have eliminated the shutdown being related? I'll admit a 100% correlation does not imply causation, but I'd like to repeat the steps you did to prove this.
Cheers,
Fork - Fork90Copper Contributor
Hello,
Sorry I don't have those number currently, but the next time I encounter the issue I will be sure to record that as well as a few other things so we have a clean picture.
In the meantime, you sound very certain in your dismissal of the shutdown issue being related despite a 100% correlation. I'm completely aware correlation does not imply causation, however can you explain when you had physical access to my machine and what experiments you ran to conclude this? I would like to independently verify your results.Cheers,
Fork