Forum Discussion
Entra ID Launches New MemberOf Operator for Dynamic Membership Groups
Yes — Microsoft almost certainly knew that a replacement was being developed when it announced the retirement in August 2026. However, there is no public evidence proving exactly when the decision was made or what Microsoft knew at that point.
There are three reasons Microsoft's handling deserves criticism:
1. Poor communication: Microsoft retired the old preview in early November and announced MemberOf Next just two weeks later. The replacement architecture was likely already well advanced.
2. Unnecessary customer work: Customers were advised to remove or redesign existing dynamic membership rules, potentially wasting considerable administrative effort.
3. Unexpected licensing costs: The old implementation required Entra ID P1, whereas the replacement requires Entra ID Governance, increasing costs for some customers.
My take: Microsoft should have been transparent in August that a replacement was under development, even if it couldn't promise a delivery date.
Retiring a feature because it has reliability problems is understandable. Failing to communicate an imminent replacement — particularly one with different licensing requirements — is poor customer management.
The bigger issue isn't the technology. It's customer trust.