Forum Discussion
Text to columns
Axle-Flipps_1 I am having the exact same problem! Did you find a solution? Even when I replaced all of the carriage returns with a comma for instance, it still isn't working. I'll select a bunch of rows, but even the preview will only show the separated results for the first row/cell. If I start the process over again one row down, it will then give me the separated results for that row. I cannot for the life of me figure this out!
- SnowMan55Oct 19, 2022Bronze Contributor
As this seems to be a problem many people (including myself) have encountered...
How about executing a VBA procedure (shown below) to split the text? You would not have to save the VBA procedure in the workbook; you could either create it in your PERSONAL.xlsb file, or just store it in the workbook temporarily, and delete the code after use.
Sub SplitTextToColumns() ' This procedure will split the text in a column of the currently- ' selected row into separate adjacent columns in the same row. ' The split occurs where a particular delimiter is found, which ' is specified by the user. ' The procedure splits the text in all rows from the current row down ' until it reaches an empty cell (or a cell with an empty string ' value) in the source-text column. Code is included to warn the ' user if some non-empty string value is about to be overwritten. Const strPROCEDURE_NAME As String = "SplitTextToColumns" Dim strWorksheetName As String ' Dim strMessage As String Dim in4UserResponse As VbMsgBoxResult ' Dim strDelimiter As String Dim strSourceCol As String ' Dim in4CurrentRow As Long Dim objRange As Range Dim strCellContent As String Dim strPieces() As String Dim in4PieceIndex As Long Dim in4RelativeCol As Long '---- Determine the active worksheet and row. strWorksheetName = ActiveSheet.Name in4CurrentRow = ActiveCell.Row '---- Get confirmation and option choices from the user. strMessage = "Are you sure you want to split cell contents" _ & " in worksheet " & strWorksheetName _ & ", starting at row " & CStr(in4CurrentRow) _ & " and overwriting adjacent columns to the right?" in4UserResponse = MsgBox(strMessage, vbQuestion Or vbYesNo _ Or vbDefaultButton2, strPROCEDURE_NAME) If in4UserResponse = vbNo Then Exit Sub End If ' -- Prompt for the column. strMessage = "Which column contains the text to be split? (Enter" _ & " the letter(s).)" strSourceCol = InputBox(strMessage, strPROCEDURE_NAME, "A") If strSourceCol = "" Then strMessage = "That's required information. Quitting." Call MsgBox(strMessage, vbInformation Or vbOKOnly, strPROCEDURE_NAME) Exit Sub ElseIf Len(strSourceCol) > 3 Then strMessage = "Invalid input. Quitting." Call MsgBox(strMessage, vbInformation Or vbOKOnly, strPROCEDURE_NAME) Exit Sub ElseIf Len(strSourceCol) = 3 _ And UCase$(strSourceCol) >= "XED" Then strMessage = "Too far to the right. Quitting." '...that far out, the text is likely to be split beyond the ' available columns. Call MsgBox(strMessage, vbInformation Or vbOKOnly, strPROCEDURE_NAME) Exit Sub Else strSourceCol = UCase$(strSourceCol) End If ' -- Prompt for the delimiter. strMessage = "Enter the delimiter character, or TAB or LF or CR" _ & " for a special character:" strDelimiter = InputBox(strMessage, strPROCEDURE_NAME) If strDelimiter = "" Then strMessage = "That's required information. Quitting." Call MsgBox(strMessage, vbInformation Or vbOKOnly, strPROCEDURE_NAME) Exit Sub ElseIf UCase$(strDelimiter) = "TAB" Then strDelimiter = Chr(9) 'tab character ElseIf UCase$(strDelimiter) = "LF" Then strDelimiter = Chr(10) 'line feed character ElseIf UCase$(strDelimiter) = "CR" Then strDelimiter = Chr(13) 'carriage return character ElseIf Len(strDelimiter) > 1 Then strMessage = "Invalid input. Quitting." Call MsgBox(strMessage, vbInformation Or vbOKOnly, strPROCEDURE_NAME) Exit Sub Else 'Use the value in strDelimiter as-is. End If '---- Process the current row and following rows. With Worksheets(strWorksheetName) Do Set objRange = .Range(strSourceCol & CStr(in4CurrentRow)) objRange.Select ' strCellContent = Selection.Value If strCellContent = "" Then '...we're done. strMessage = "Stopping at 'empty' cell in row " _ & CStr(in4CurrentRow) Call MsgBox(strMessage, vbInformation Or vbOKOnly) Exit Do End If ' -- Do the work for this row. strPieces = Split(strCellContent, strDelimiter) For in4PieceIndex = 0 To UBound(strPieces) in4RelativeCol = in4PieceIndex + 1 strCellContent = objRange.Offset(0, in4RelativeCol).Value If strCellContent <> "" Then strMessage = "WARNING! Row " & CStr(in4CurrentRow) _ & " is not empty in a destination cell. Is It" _ & " OK to overwrite the contents of this row?" in4UserResponse = MsgBox(strMessage _ , vbExclamation Or vbYesNoCancel Or vbDefaultButton2 _ , strPROCEDURE_NAME) If in4UserResponse = vbNo Then GoTo NextRow ElseIf in4UserResponse = vbCancel Then Exit Do Else '...continue with the user's permission. End If End If objRange.Offset(0, in4RelativeCol).Value = _ strPieces(in4PieceIndex) Next in4PieceIndex NextRow: ' -- Advance a row. in4CurrentRow = in4CurrentRow + 1 Application.Goto Reference:="R" & CStr(in4CurrentRow) _ & "C1" DoEvents Loop End With End Sub
If you find that your invisible delimiter is not a line feed character (LF) or a carriage return character (CR), you can add code following the comment "Prompt for the delimiter" to handle a different delimiter.
2023-03 addendum: Before/during September 2022 (shortly before I posted this solution), Microsoft added the built-in function TEXTSPLIT to the latest versions of Excel. TEXTSPLIT also supports the use of multiple delimiters in one pass. So while the VBA code above is still usable (and of course, can be customized for special circumstances), the use of TEXTSPLIT might be a better, quicker choice.
- macwombatJul 21, 2023Copper Contributor
SnowMan55 oh wow!!!! Thank you so much. I tried using the TEXTSPLIT and couldn't get it to work, but your VBA procedure worked a treat! I had never used Visual Basic in a spreadsheet before, but it was pretty easy to do with your code. Thank you, thank you, thank you. There were fist pumps in the air when it worked!!
- SergeiBaklanJul 21, 2023Diamond Contributor
Why don't combination of TEXTJOIN/TEXTSPLIT doesn't work?
- SarahD33Oct 20, 2022Copper ContributorUm, this is amazing and it worked with the CR!
To reply to dscheikey, I was using Ctrl J in the Find and Replace function to (I guess hopefully) get rid of all of the carriage returns, but obviously it didn't work.
This is the very first time I've posted somewhere and gotten an answer that worked. Thank you x 1,000,000 SnowMan55!
- dscheikeyOct 19, 2022Bronze Contributor
Hello Sarah, could you provide some of your data to be able to perform an analysis here. Without the original data that does not work, it can not work.
If you can't share documents here, then please use another file sharing service and post the link here.
BTW: What is CTRL+ J for a shortcut. Where does it do something? Is it a character or formatting in a program? Is it from the Mac? It doesn't seem to do anything in Excel on Windows.