Forum Discussion

ECD333285's avatar
ECD333285
Copper Contributor
Jul 04, 2024
Solved

Sorting on multiples in same column

Hi there - Cannot figure this out. I have a list of items in a column as follows: 5" White 5" Red 5" Blue 11" White 11" Red 11" Blue 17" White 17" Red 17" Blue There are several more sizes ...
excel
Formulas and Functions
  • djclements's avatar
    djclements
    Jul 10, 2024

    ECD333285 No worries. The original formula sorted the data alphanumerically, treating the sizes as text (anything that begins with a "1" appears first, then "2" and so on. To sort them in a specified order, you can create an array of sizes in the order of your choosing, then use the XMATCH method again to generate the size_ID. For example, the formula for Excel 2021 could be modified as follows:

     

    =LET(
    data, FILTER(A2:A1000, A2:A1000<>""),
    num, SEARCH(" ", data),
    color, RIGHT(data, LEN(data) - num),
    color_ID, XMATCH(color, UNIQUE(color)),
    size, --LEFT(data, num - 2),
    size_ID, XMATCH(size, {11;17;5;24;36}),
    SORTBY(data, color_ID, 1, size_ID, 1)
)

     

    Also, if you run into the same problem with the colors not sorting in the preferred order, you could replace UNIQUE(color) with an array of colors in the order of your choosing. For example:

     

    =LET(
    data, FILTER(A2:A1000, A2:A1000<>""),
    num, SEARCH(" ", data),
    color, RIGHT(data, LEN(data) - num),
    color_ID, XMATCH(color, {"White";"Red";"Blue";"Yellow"}),
    size, --LEFT(data, num - 2),
    size_ID, XMATCH(size, {11;17;5;24;36}),
    SORTBY(data, color_ID, 1, size_ID, 1)
)

     

    As an aside, I've defined variables for each step in the examples shown above so they're easy to understand and follow, but the same formula(s) can also be written with fewer steps:

     

    =LET(
    data, FILTER(A2:A1000, A2:A1000<>""),
    num, SEARCH(" ", data),
    SORTBY(
        data,
        XMATCH(RIGHT(data, LEN(data) - num), {"White";"Red";"Blue";"Yellow"}), 1,
        XMATCH(--LEFT(data, num - 2), {11;17;5;24;36}), 1
    )
)

     

    I hope that works as expected. Cheers!

djclements's avatar
djclements
Bronze Contributor
Jul 06, 2024

ECD333285 The #NAME? error is a pretty strong indication that your version of Excel does not support one or more of the functions used in my first example. TOCOL, TEXTBEFORE and TEXTAFTER are currently only available in Excel for MS365 (subscription).

 

If you are using Excel 2021, a compatible variant of the formula would be:

 

=LET(
    data, FILTER(A2:A1000, A2:A1000<>""),
    color, RIGHT(data, LEN(data) - SEARCH(" ", data)),
    color_ID, XMATCH(color, UNIQUE(color)),
    SORTBY(data, color_ID, 1, data, 1)
)

 

LET, FILTER, XMATCH, UNIQUE and SORTBY are all available in Excel 2021 and later versions, according to Microsoft documentation.

 

If you are using Excel 2019 or an earlier version, add a helper column to your dataset to assign the ColorID by matching each color to a list or table of colors. For example:

 

=MATCH(RIGHT(A2, LEN(A2) - SEARCH(" ", A2)), tblColors[Color], 0)

 

...where tblColors is a structured Excel table (created by going to Insert > Table on the ribbon).

 

Table: tblColors

 

Then, sort the data by going to Home > Sort & Filter > Custom Sort... and sort by ColorID, then by Size/Color:

 

Home > Sort & Filter > Custom Sort...

 

Custom Sort Results

 

Please download the attached sample workbook, if needed, which contains all of the above-mentioned examples.

 

EDIT: if a helper column is required, you could also just extract the Color...

 

=RIGHT(A2, LEN(A2) - SEARCH(" ", A2))

 

...then use a Custom List to sort by Color, then by Size/Color.

 

For more information, please see: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/sort-data-using-a-custom-list... 

ECD333285's avatar
ECD333285
Copper Contributor
Jul 10, 2024
Hi - Thanks very much the formula for Excel 2021 works just right! Another question arises in that when I include the additional sizes the order isn't controlled. I'm not clear what is used to order the sizes. I should have included this in the original post. The sizes I'm hoping to order as:
11
17
5
24
36
I'd like to understand how the sizes get sorted so I can substitute some different orders without having to bug the community 🙂

Thanks!
  • djclements's avatar
    djclements
    Bronze Contributor
    Jul 10, 2024

    ECD333285 No worries. The original formula sorted the data alphanumerically, treating the sizes as text (anything that begins with a "1" appears first, then "2" and so on. To sort them in a specified order, you can create an array of sizes in the order of your choosing, then use the XMATCH method again to generate the size_ID. For example, the formula for Excel 2021 could be modified as follows:

     

    =LET(
    data, FILTER(A2:A1000, A2:A1000<>""),
    num, SEARCH(" ", data),
    color, RIGHT(data, LEN(data) - num),
    color_ID, XMATCH(color, UNIQUE(color)),
    size, --LEFT(data, num - 2),
    size_ID, XMATCH(size, {11;17;5;24;36}),
    SORTBY(data, color_ID, 1, size_ID, 1)
)

     

    Also, if you run into the same problem with the colors not sorting in the preferred order, you could replace UNIQUE(color) with an array of colors in the order of your choosing. For example:

     

    =LET(
    data, FILTER(A2:A1000, A2:A1000<>""),
    num, SEARCH(" ", data),
    color, RIGHT(data, LEN(data) - num),
    color_ID, XMATCH(color, {"White";"Red";"Blue";"Yellow"}),
    size, --LEFT(data, num - 2),
    size_ID, XMATCH(size, {11;17;5;24;36}),
    SORTBY(data, color_ID, 1, size_ID, 1)
)

     

    As an aside, I've defined variables for each step in the examples shown above so they're easy to understand and follow, but the same formula(s) can also be written with fewer steps:

     

    =LET(
    data, FILTER(A2:A1000, A2:A1000<>""),
    num, SEARCH(" ", data),
    SORTBY(
        data,
        XMATCH(RIGHT(data, LEN(data) - num), {"White";"Red";"Blue";"Yellow"}), 1,
        XMATCH(--LEFT(data, num - 2), {11;17;5;24;36}), 1
    )
)

     

    I hope that works as expected. Cheers!

Resources