Searching Activate Worksheet window

I have Office Home and Student 2019 and I recently upgraded to a new computer so I had to reinstall my Office. I have a workbook with over a hundred worksheets on it, each with its own unique label, but many of them similar, such as 'Red1', 'Red2', 'Red3' etc. If I right-click on the two arrows at the bottom-left of the workbook, to the left of the list of worksheets, it shows me a list of all my worksheets in a popup window so I can select the one I want. In order to search the worksheets in this window, I can start typing the name of the worksheet and it will then automatically select the worksheet based on what I have typed. On my old computer, if I then waited a few seconds and started typing again, it will then continue searching through all the subsequent worksheets in the list. So for example, if I started by typing 'Red', it would find 'Red1', then if I started typing 'Red' again, it would find 'Red2', and again for 'Red3' etc. But now on my new computer, every time I type 'Red', it just finds 'Red1', regardless of how many times I type 'Red'. If I want to find 'Red2', I have to type 'Red2', which is a bit annoying. I'm sure there has to be a setting for this somewhere but I can't find it. Anyone have any ideas on this?