Forum Discussion
Rules across Sheets
3 Replies
Are you at all open to re-thinking your whole approach? Whenever I see somebody talking of separate sheets for each month (or other sequential variable), I worry that they're taking a process that resembles a previously existing paper process and using Excel and the computer in an effort to "automate" it. But not to rethink it in light of the capabilities of the computer.
I have a budget spreadsheet too (and there are many templates for such things available through Microsoft among other sources).....I created my own. There is a single database for all expenses, all months and years, all accounts [checking (X 2), credit cards (X 5)], multiple budget categories and sub-categories for each expense. I use Excel's built-in Pivot Table function to create, from that single database, reports of expense by-category, by-month.
Basic point, let Excel do the heavy lifting of breaking line items out into coherent summaries by month (or whatever); don't get in the way by creating separate sheets for each month. Your question here is just one example of that interference that "manually" separating the data by month can cause.
Excel works very well to parse apart a single database; let it. It's a lot more effective than taking monthly sheets and trying to make them work together in a coherent way.
You are proposing I use a separate database entirely, and export it to Excel? That would make the experience more streamlined?
Not at all. I'm proposing not having monthly spreadsheets that essentially contain information all laid out in the same manner. Combine those into a single database IN Excel (adding a column, if needed, that contains the date, to serve as the basis for differentiating by month), IN the same workbook where you could use the Pivot Table (or other methods) to create summary reports on that transactional data.
When you have, for example, all your utility payments in separate sheets, depending on which month(s) they got paid, it's tricky to put together a summary. You have to draw from multiple sheets just to see trends, say, in electricity expenses. But if all of your payments, of every type, are in a single spreadsheet (organized as an Excel table), it is simplicity itself to produce reports that analyze trends by month by payee, by budget category.
I've attached an example that is not meant to do any more than show how a single database (AKA a "table") can serve as the source for a Pivot Table that yields summary amounts by month, by category. This is a very simple example. The Pivot Table is an incredibly powerful tool for taking huge amounts of data of this type and breaking it apart in cross-tabulated manner.
