Controlled and Commented Changes in Excel Spreadsheet

Hello,

I am currently searching for a solution or method that would enable me to implement advanced change control in an Excel spreadsheet. My requirements are quite specific, and so far, I haven't found a built-in feature in Excel or an external add-on that fully satisfies them. Here's what I need:

1. Change Control: I want every change made in the sheet to be recorded in a way that prevents users from unauthorized disabling. All changes should be tracked without the possibility for users to circumvent this mechanism.

2. Commenting on Changes: Every change in the sheet should require the user to add a comment explaining the reason for the change. This is crucial for auditing and tracking the change history.

3. Visibility and Accessibility of Change History: I need easy access to the history of changes, including who made the change, when it was made, what the previous value was, and what comment was added.

I realize that the standard change tracking features in Excel do not offer all the functionalities I require, especially regarding the requirement for comments on each change and constant change control. I have considered using VBA or external add-ons, but I would prefer to avoid overly complicated or unconventional solutions that might be difficult to maintain.

Has anyone encountered a similar challenge and found an effective solution? Are there any tools or add-ons that could meet these requirements? Any help or pointers would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you in advance for any suggestions and assistance.