Combine and align columns of data

clamb2060 Easiest with Power Query (PQ). Are you familiar with that?

The attached workbook demonstrates a PQ solution. It's quick-and-dirty and far from perfect. Created structured tables from each of the score lists and queried them.

Your data is not clean as it contains scores from (presumably) the same persons but with their names spelled slightly different.

For example: 

Alexis R ( Alexis R ) vs. AlexisR ( Alexis R )

Elliot is verified ( Elliot L ) vs. Elliott is verified ( Elliot L )

and there are many more.

As the name between brackets seemed to be consistent, I used these to extract player names and create the table (in sheet Query1) with scores for each player.

As said, far from perfect, but I hope it gives you an idea of what is possible with PQ, in case you want to pursue this further. Otherwise, VLOOKUP or XlOOKUP will work as well, but you need to check and clean your data, and add a column with the V(X)LOOKUP formula, for every new score table you add. With PQ that goes automatic, provided all is set-up correctly.