Changed format to Webpage, how to change it back?

I am working on a very large document (a court transcript) which I hope to post online. 

It has been in a Word Document, but as it was scanned in there were numerous changes I had to make to clean up the OCR.

I have done that and saved it, then because I wanted to see what it would look like as a Word-created webpage, I saved it (under a different filename) to a different folder. It looked pretty crappy as all the bolds, page breaks, and other formatting seems to have been stripped out of it.

I figured this was no big deal, because I could open up the previous saved version, before I saved it as HTML, and just try a different way. 

But when I open up the other versions, even in RTF mode, they still look like the webpage version, which is really frustrating.

Does anyone have any ideas to fix this?