Dec 29 2020 05:04 AM
We have 5 active directory 3 virtual machine and 2 physical , should hold 5 role fsmo into virtual or physical server ?
Dec 29 2020 07:21 AM - edited Dec 29 2020 07:46 AM
Assuming the availability is equal then physical/virtual would not be a consideration. Some guidelines here on roles placement.
FSMO placement and optimization on AD DCs - Windows Server | Microsoft Docs
Jan 08 2021 03:14 AM
@Dave PatrickI can hold all role in one server ? and if this server failure then i can resize fsmo another server ?
Jan 08 2021 03:27 AM
I remember old in the days, Windows 2003, the recommendation was to have the FSMO and the PDC in a physical, for timing issues and sync as the hardware will provide better accuracy, but I don't think this is applicable these days.
So if its on Virtual or Physical and you are maintaining the HA, then no worry.
Jan 08 2021 06:49 AM
I can hold all role in one server ? and if this server failure then i can resize fsmo another server ?
Yes, that's correct.
Transfer or seize FSMO roles - Windows Server | Microsoft Docs
Jan 08 2021 06:51 AM
So if its on Virtual or Physical and you are maintaining the HA, then no worry.
Yes, no worries, just configure affinity so that all domain controllers would not migrate to a single host.