Forum Discussion

Deleted's avatar
Deleted
Jan 23, 2021

Micorsoft Edge Smartscreen didnt' protect me

 

 

As you can see that I have a download from Edge from a website that edge allowed to open even though Defender said it is unsafe to open the download. 

 

This is very funny and I dont' see the scanning file in the download UI anymore.

 

I already sent feedback,

 

Thank you,

 

Shawn

 
  • Wittycat's avatar
    Wittycat
    Steel Contributor
    And it's better like that because i don't want edge to refuse to download a "potential" treath, because it can be a good software
    • Deleted's avatar
      Deleted
      That is very true but I dont' see the scanning file for virus anymore.

      Well if isnt' low reputation apps known as uwa? It should block it and say run anyways.
      • Wittycat's avatar
        Wittycat
        Steel Contributor
        yes i have (at the first version of edge) asked to have in the download history the result of smartscreen "normal" or "warning" but i must be the only one to have asked since it never have come.
  • Wittycat's avatar
    Wittycat
    Steel Contributor
    Be warry don't mistake the work of smartscreen for edge and windows defender smartscreen.
    The first only check if the file is a bad file. The Second check potential threaths and a file who is not seen (firstime seen or blocked (right click you will see a case to check unblock)) it will trigger this warning
    • Deleted's avatar
      Deleted
      Yes, I believe that Edge is the best for safety protection since it was the number one browser in the NSS Browser Lab report.

      The thing is that Edge didn't block the app even though it was blocked by Windows Defender on Windows desktop..



      I just tried to open the download, I didnt' trigger anything

      • Wittycat's avatar
        Wittycat
        Steel Contributor
        sometime i have this warning when smartscreen windows can't connecte itself to internet (one or two time a year)
    • Deleted's avatar
      Deleted
      Yes, I see your very point but I do think Edge should be more smart. Since there isnt' much consistency since they are both windows defender

Resources