04-08-2019 09:35 AM
04-08-2019 09:35 AM
I didn't expect to see all my Chrome bookmarks on Edge first launch. It should have asked me before importing them. Or if the issue is that it's looking at Chrome's bookmark DB, that's unideal.
04-08-2019 09:41 AM
04-08-2019 09:43 AM
@Alejandro Barreto Same for me. I was expecting to see my existing Edge favorites, if anything.
04-08-2019 09:45 AM - edited 04-08-2019 09:46 AM
I expected Edge to ask me before importing my bookmarks. What if I wanted to start anew, with a fresh experience? What if I am privacy advocate and would be upset if Microsoft took my bookmarks without my permission? What if I wanted to import bookmarks from a different browser; e.g. Firefox (which I also have installed)?
I'm OK if it asks me during the install wizard. But it shouldn't just do it.
04-08-2019 12:43 PM
I have a few browsers installed, including Chrome, Firefox, Opera, and more - each with their different uses and favorites - yet here it imported my Old Edge favorites and didn't import a single thing from Chrome, so I'm surprised at how it behaved on your installation. Maybe it imports automatically from the default browser ? Original Edge was my default so it would make sense.
04-08-2019 01:43 PM
@AmineI I have no bookmarks in Edge, so it couldn't have come from there. Chrome is my default browser so your theory is plausible.
04-08-2019 02:34 PM
@AmineI Edge was my default browser. I had to go into settings after installation to import those favorites. I don't recall it asking about importing favorites during the install. I thought I noticed something about enabling sync which I did thinking that would pull in favorites and possibly passwords.
04-08-2019 04:12 PM
@Alejandro Barreto while I was surprised to see edge soak up all my chrome data, I'm not mad at it. This is by far my most beloved feature of this browser.
Plus, it says it:
You did confirm, so as for most "problems" we all know the source of this one.
I see your point though. Importing data is an important step and maybe should have a seperate popup, which isn't easily confirmed. Maybe a selection, which forces you to choose which, if any data should be imported.
04-08-2019 04:59 PM
I wanted Edge Dev to import my Edge favorites. It imported from Chrome. This will cause trouble if it synced with my Microsoft account (I have separate sets of favorites).
Now how do I delete the Edge Dev favorites and start again? I uninstalled and re-installed - the Chrome favorites returned.
The User Date folder is empty. - C:\Users\MYUSERNAME\AppData\Roaming\Microsoft\Edge Dev\User Data
04-08-2019 05:51 PM
04-08-2019 05:51 PM
04-09-2019 01:32 AM
@Cedup You're right. I installed Edge Preview on another computer and saw the same screen. I must have just clicked through quickly. User error, yes.
Yet I still stand by this issue. That dialog looks like a tip. I always click through tips so I can get going faster. I did not expect to see my bookmarks because I didn't believe I had made a choice to add them. The dialog could be designed so that it stands out more, or forces you to make a decision instead of just "Confirm".
04-09-2019 03:40 AM
Yes, it kind of freaked me out when I saw all my Chrome Bookmarks on here. Edge should have asked me before doing this.
04-09-2019 03:44 AMSolution
Thank you@Alejandro Barreto and everyone else, for trying out the preview builds and really appreciate the feedback.
The way the first-run experience on preview builds works currently is: it picks your most-used browser as a recommendation for you to "Start with your data" imported from that browser. Alternatively, you can "Start from scratch" (which sets up the browser without importing any data) or choose to import from a different browser/profile instead using the "Customize import & sync" option.
From what we've heard so far: the "Customize import & sync" option is not quite noticeable in its current form -- and we intend to work on improving it's discoverability, so that you can easily pick a specific browser/profile to import from. Stay tuned for improvements and we look forward to yoru feedback.
04-09-2019 04:51 AM
@KoshyG again, it did. Like the OP said, it did ask him, but he confirmed it too quickly, because the dialogue looks like some kind of beginner information.
I think it's not fair to state that the browser did this without your permission. You all did click confirm. At least this dialogue was there for me since the very beginning of the unofficial release.
Maybe this raises your attention not to click OK on every single dialogue.
I'm with @Alejandro Barreto though, it could be made more obvious about what is going to happen.
PSA: You can manually synch EdgeChromium with all your browsers. Check the images below:
04-09-2019 04:58 AM
@Cedup This is not true, on first install Edge automatically shows all your bookmarks from your most used broweser in Edge, there is an option to remove it but it shows up by default. I chose not to import from chrome but it's alamring to see your chrome bookmarks in Edge on first install.
04-09-2019 05:22 AM
Exactly this @KoshyG . As visible in the first screenshot in the thread, it already has the bookmarks imported when it asks if you want to continue from your data or start from scratch.
04-09-2019 10:08 AM
04-09-2019 02:22 PM
This is a great thread, and I have forwarded the whole conversation on to the people who are responsible for the first run experience. Thank you all for being so passionate, and for taking the time to offer us this feedback.
04-09-2019 03:43 PM - edited 04-09-2019 03:45 PM
"it did ask him, but he confirmed it too quickly, because the dialogue looks like some kind of beginner information"
I did the same. Edge and IE/Windows have a history of opening a tab or two of tips or welcome info that I don't care about (such as IE's "you should use Edge" page), so I instinctivly close it without looking at it. On the other hand, IE's "Set up Internet Explorer 11" dialogue is fairly intrusive by forcing me to make a decision before I can use the browser (and it takes a few seconds to pop up). Maybe there's a happy medium inbetween those options.
I'm no UX designer, but the problem I had with the Edge import/first run is that it's cluttered with too much text, choices, and instructional images. The title doesn't make it clear what the page is about. The option for "start with your data" requires reading the sentence above the diagram to have a context on the vague word "data". Having options and a confirm button seems excessive. Why not just have 2 primary options: "Import from [Chrome/whatever browser]" and "Start from scratch" that only take one click? I do like the "customize import and sync" choice. It's not intrusive and it's not hard to find.
Look at the Brave first run wizard. The things I notice about it: 1) the big, bold "import bookmarks and settings" title makes it clear what's happening without reading the detailed text, and 2) I have 2 simple choices: "import" and "next". I can make a decision after reading 6 words. The Edge wizard requires reading 18 words, and at that point "data" still hasn't been defined. It takes another 12 words to know what "data" is.
And now for what I think Edge does better. The autodetection of where to import from is nice. It only takes one click, if the detection determined my primary browser correctly (which was true in my case). All other import wizards I've seen force me to choose from a drop down list and usually don't have the correct one selected by default.