Forum Discussion
Microsoft To Do – Cannot join shared lists between two personal Microsoft accounts
Hello Microsoft Support Community,
I am experiencing a persistent issue with Microsoft To Do list sharing between two personal Microsoft accounts.
Account configuration:
- Account 1: Personal Microsoft account registered with Gmail.
- Account 2: Personal Microsoft account using Hotmail.
- Subscription: Microsoft 365 Family.
Both accounts can independently sign in to Microsoft To Do and use the application without any issues.
Problem:
Neither account can join a list shared by the other.
The following error appears:
"Lists can only be shared between personal accounts, or between work or school accounts in the same organization."
Both accounts are personal Microsoft accounts, so this restriction should not apply.
Troubleshooting already completed:
- Verified that both accounts are personal Microsoft accounts.
- Tested sharing in both directions (Gmail → Hotmail and Hotmail → Gmail).
- Created completely new test lists.
- Generated new sharing invitation links.
- Tested using Chrome Incognito mode.
- Tested across Chrome browser and Android devices.
- Confirmed that both accounts can access Microsoft To Do independently.
The problem persists in every scenario.
Assistance requested:
Could you please investigate the following?
- Whether either account is incorrectly identified as a work or school account by the To Do sharing service.
- Whether there are account-level restrictions affecting list sharing.
- Whether there is a backend issue with the Microsoft To Do sharing service.
- Whether this issue can be escalated to the Microsoft To Do product or engineering team.
I would appreciate technical assistance rather than further generic recommendations to reinstall the application or clear browser cache, as these steps have already been effectively ruled out.
Thank you for your assistance.
16 Replies
- Samuel678Copper Contributor
We're having the same issue, trying to share a list between 2 personal accounts. We've done this in the past, without any issues.
- psarabiCopper Contributor
i Have the Same problem ! im thinking to change my todo APP !
- AtahualpaCopper Contributor
Same issue here.
2 personal free accounts. Both registered with non-microsoft email. Sharing Lists worked fine in 2026. Had the identical issues 2025 and somehow MS resolved those. Now the same issues is back.
I tried joining the shared list on my phone and on two desktop devices. The issue is the same in both directions. I used to be able to share lists und join them with my friend. Now neither of us can share lists with one another.
I'm already looking for an alternative app solution!
PLEASE MS fix this! - paul_moloneyBrass Contributor
Yes I am getting the same issue too with my account and my wife's. Both personal. Is it related to the fact we have purchased a family 365 account? In that case I might simply unsubscribe....
- Arthur_LaserTin Contributor
That shouldn't be the problem. We have tried it with the family 365 subscription as well as with accounts without the subscription on several devices and it doesn't work. i have talked to the support team 5 times and nobody could help there either
- koktaleCopper Contributor
Same issue. Very annoying. Please fix this ASAP!!! Thank you
- kubrayasaarCopper Contributor
I am experiencing exactly the same issue. All accounts are personal Microsoft accounts. Existing shared lists work, but new users cannot join any lists. We tested different accounts, devices, browsers, networks and newly created lists without success. Microsoft Support could not resolve the problem and referred me here. Could the To Do engineering team investigate this issue and provide an update?
- kubrayasaarCopper Contributor
I am experiencing exactly the same issue. All accounts are personal Microsoft accounts. Existing shared lists work, but new users cannot join any lists. We tested different accounts, devices, browsers, networks and newly created lists without success. Microsoft Support could not resolve the problem and referred me here. Could the To Do engineering team investigate this issue and provide an update?
- yvenavarreteCopper Contributor
I'm experiencing the same problem with my husband, we're trying to share a 'to do' list and we received the same error message
- Arthur_LaserTin Contributor
I have the same problem and the described troubleshooting did not work too.
- RaffaellaCopper Contributor
Microsoft To Do – Unable to Join Shared Lists Between Personal Accounts
We are experiencing an issue with Microsoft To Do list sharing between two recently created personal Microsoft accounts.
Both accounts use different email addresses with the same domain and work correctly for individual task management.
However, sharing lists is not possible in either direction. Invitation links are generated successfully, but when the recipient tries to join, the following error appears:
"Can't join list. It looks like this list isn't available."
The issue occurs on both the Windows application and the web version. We have never been able to successfully share lists between these accounts.
We noticed that a similar issue was reported under incident MO1213801, which was apparently resolved in January 2026.
Could this be a recurrence of the same issue? Is there any known solution or workaround?
We would appreciate your assistance, as we would like to use Microsoft To Do for shared task management.
Thank you in advance for your support.