Forum Discussion

cjc2112's avatar
cjc2112
Bronze Contributor
Sep 18, 2019
Solved

Tabs and Dark Mode

Elliot Kirk I feel that the dark mode isn't as contrasting as the dark mode in the original edge. When I tried it in the original, I was entranced by the dark modes near complete black color(1). The new edge has a dark gray color that does not look as contrasting(2).

(1) (2)

The new edge active tab is lighter than the other tabs and looks similar to chrome, however, if it were like the original edge, it would add personality to the browser. 

The original edge uses shadows to make the active tab appear to pop out a little bit from the other tabs, which is only helpful with 90 degree angles, so this would be nice to implement at the same time. Another part that made the dark mode so attractive is when the mouse hovered over an area, that area would lighten up a bit.

Lighter areas and slight pop out effect example:

Tabs also were able to slide under each other.

Another issue is that there isn't an option to make the background of the new tab page dark. It would add to the aesthetics if you were able to customize the color of the new tab page background.Edit: the last tab has been turned dark for a while now.

  • Somehow I think making the UI as close to the original Edge should be the top priority in the new Edge. It still looks like a slightly reskinned Chrome...

51 Replies

  • Graham-STMC's avatar
    Graham-STMC
    Iron Contributor
    I love this suggestion because it offers clarity to each tab, flexibility to the user, it brings some of the nicer features of "Classic Edge" to Edge Chromium and yet differentiates Edge from Chrome.
  • I hate the fact that tabs slide under each other in Edge Spartan. It makes me so frustrated. I love the way Chromium handles tabs

    I agree on the appearance of tabs, the hover effect on tabs and the omnibox in dark mode though!

  • Drew1903's avatar
    Drew1903
    Silver Contributor

    cjc2112 

    Hi,

    I have 3 comments:

    1. I find when hoovering things do change such that it is quite noticeable, to me.
    2. You can move the tabs laterally, the same as w/ Edge.
    3. If the OS is set to Dark & certain OS Accent colours are used one can have very good contrast across the Edge C top bar. 

    Cheers,
    Drew

    • erikvp's avatar
      erikvp
      Brass Contributor

      Drew1903 

       

      Hi Drew,

       

      Hovering over a tab makes it lighter. But I never noticed it till I did read this and tried it. So, it is clearly not enough it should be made lighter. Don't forget a good part of the population is color blind to some degree. So, trying to be making it just a bit different will not work for them 

      • Drew1903's avatar
        Drew1903
        Silver Contributor

        erikvp 

        Yes, Erik, the shading changes when hoovering on a tab.  I will tell you (& others) since Edge C does a very good job of applying OS Accent colours when they are told to affect Title Bars & window frames, things can be very easy to see & distinguish.  For example...



        Cheers,
        Drew

  • cjc2112's avatar
    cjc2112
    Bronze Contributor

    cjc2112 

    I'm going to go into more detail here on the colors to homepage. I already posted this, but can't figure out how to link it, so I'm posting it here as well.

    I used Inspect element to add different colors to the new tab page, and think Microsoft should consider this. Elliot Kirk.

    This is the current default dark theme for the focused NTP:This is the default dark theme

    These are the new ones:

    BlackBlueGreenRedSky blueYellow

    I'm colorblind and can't see purple(it just looks like a different shade of blue. I'm told I can't see the red. I wouldn't know) so I didn't bother trying to find it, and I apologize if the blue is actually purple.

    • Drew1903's avatar
      Drew1903
      Silver Contributor

      cjc2112 

      Cameron,

       

      That's cool with various page colours.  It does have nice daily photos, often, too.


      Notice how visible the tabs are.


      Cheers,
      Drew

      • cjc2112's avatar
        cjc2112
        Bronze Contributor

        Drew1903 I made the color ones specifically for the focused NTP, so if you could personalize even if you want something minimalistic and not distracting.

         

        Your tabs are very visible, however, the dark mode in Spartan edge allows contrast without switching your themes.

    • pneenkoalabear's avatar
      pneenkoalabear
      Iron Contributor
      I love it! Similarly, Google Chrome has NTP customisation with a colour picker! It even themes the browser!
  • Somehow I think making the UI as close to the original Edge should be the top priority in the new Edge. It still looks like a slightly reskinned Chrome...
    • Woodykirk's avatar
      Woodykirk
      Copper Contributor

      Deleted The Dark mode regardless of texture etc. is a godsend to me personally as with the darker screen and white lettering it is surely the best option and in my case, (very poor eyesight) it is a no brainer, so needless to say it is is an assett regardless, but it would be cool to have say variable darker colours, (dark Blue, Deep Red and the like) just to jazz it up a tad perhaps! It is an absolute necessity to me!

      • cjc2112's avatar
        cjc2112
        Bronze Contributor

        Woodykirk Today, they changed the dark omnibox from pure black to light gray and its annoying to see the lack of contrast after knowing what it was before.

    • Mike_ETC's avatar
      Mike_ETC
      Brass Contributor

      Anthony , thanks for the tip about Dark Reader. Works amazingly well on most sites and has tons of configuration options. The Microsoft team working on Force Dark Mode on Web Contents could learn a thing or two from this extension. I'll use this while Microsoft works on improving the native Edge feature. 

Resources