Forum Discussion

SpeedGamerJ's avatar
SpeedGamerJ
Brass Contributor
Nov 05, 2022

Rounded Address-bar/Omnibox in latest versions of Edge

Hello. Please remove the rounded address bar in the latest versions of Edge. It does not fit with the other UI elements. 

 

  • CraterBug's avatar
    CraterBug
    Brass Contributor
    one of the reasons why I switched from chrome to edge is edge's UI, square having mild round edges
    I guess this an attempt to look like chrome
    i don't like the new shape, old shape is better
    please change it
    • Deleted's avatar
      Deleted

      Hi CraterBug 

       

      The new look is modern and Great, square is a thing of the past! Edge engineering team - must work to make the remaining elements fit into the new project.

      Finally, some novelties that are needed.

       

  • atlanto's avatar
    atlanto
    Iron Contributor

    I'm using command-line option "--disable-features=msOmniboxFocusRingRoundEmphasize" to deny this feature, it works for me for now.

    • jgahbauer's avatar
      jgahbauer
      Copper Contributor
      Hmm. Unfortunately, this does not work for me on 107.0.1418.35 stable (Win 11).
    • jgahbauer's avatar
      jgahbauer
      Copper Contributor
      atlanto, can you specify how you are able to do this? It does not work for me using Command Prompt in Win 11 with Edge 107.0.1418.35. Would be interested to know how you got it to work. Thanks.
      • tistou's avatar
        tistou
        Bronze Contributor

        jgahbauer 

         

        In an Edge shortcut (on your desktop for example), you add this command line (in shortcut properties)

         

        --disable-features=msOmniboxFocusRingRoundEmphasize

         

        At the end (in target)

         

        Then you launch Edge with this shortcut, and you must have an option that will appear in Settings

        Or to see if this shortcut should always be launched (no option in Settings)

    • SpeedGamerJ's avatar
      SpeedGamerJ
      Brass Contributor
      I can confirm this works on Edge 107.0.1418.42 on Fedora Linux 38. I will test on Windows 11.
  • airshow's avatar
    airshow
    Copper Contributor
    Agreed, its not infitting with the UI. A little unsure why people think having two diverting UI designs in one application is good... If everything were rounded like this is would be less of a problem, but the sudden desire to insert rounded boxes (like the search on the taskbar in 11) is mindbogling to me. Fluent design does not fit with this direction.
  • SpeedGamerJ's avatar
    SpeedGamerJ
    Brass Contributor
    Edge team, can you at least make it an option to use the original omnibox?
  • Socks23's avatar
    Socks23
    Copper Contributor
    I agree with this. The rectangular address bar looked better. Rounded one just doesn't fit with everything else.
  • mrfry700's avatar
    mrfry700
    Iron Contributor
    Its left-over code from Chromium when they merged the recent changes.
      • mrfry700's avatar
        mrfry700
        Iron Contributor

        SpeedGamerJIt looks awful, so hopefully it is. I assumed it was unused code because I noticed several Chrome capabilities in the most recent Canary release that aren't a part of Edge.

  • jgahbauer's avatar
    jgahbauer
    Copper Contributor

    Yes, agreed. The previous rectangle design fits better with Windows 11 UI. The rectangle also animates better when a search term is entered. 

  • CraterBug's avatar
    CraterBug
    Brass Contributor

    So…  the truth is it looks good

     

    I was afraid that they are going to implement that UI to the whole browser

    but it seems like they are not going to do. 

    I accept this as long as they are not going to use this rounded search box* shape to the whole browser

    because it will look like chrome. 

     

    [here the (rounded search box*) refers to the fully rounded search box in recent versions, before it was rounded at the edges lightly. this rounded search box is the UI(user interface) I was taking about] 

    Thanks 

     

     

    • Deleted's avatar
      Deleted

      Hi CraterBug 

      "

      because it will look like chrome.

      "

      70% of people in the world use Chrome and don't complain!

      Edge should look the same so that no one can see the difference, that's the only way you can encourage 70% of people to try Edge!

      🙂

    • SpeedGamerJ's avatar
      SpeedGamerJ
      Brass Contributor
      It doesn't look bad, it just doesn't fit well with everything else. The radius of the buttons and tabs are much smaller than the new search bar. It looks like it belongs in Google Chrome, not Edge.

Resources