Forum Discussion
Password protection for Profiles
Deleted Thanks for the suggestion! Here are some questions for you:
- Can you tell us more about the use case for this? The feature was designed for all the profiles to be used by one person, ex. a personal account and a work account.
- One of the perks of multiple profiles, especially profile switching, is the convenience. How would you feel about having a less convenient experience (due to entering a password each time?)
- Would you ideally want those passwords to be remembered by the other account? If so, wouldn't that negate any additional security?
Fawkes (they/them)
Program Manager & Community Manager - Microsoft Edge
Deleted , Thank you for asking my opinion.
Where will it be useful?
- When someone borrows our computer, We don't want them to peek at our other profile.
- To keep the Profile safe (I think both points boils down to the same but...)
Entering password every time?
- When it comes to the point of entering the password each time, I agree that it won't be comfortable, but the idea here is to secure the profile.
- When I say password protection, You should provide a toggle in the Profile settings( To On and Off)
- The reason behind toggle is, We wont be giving our computer to others all the time, so we will opt for password protection only when we give it to others.
User experience?
- There might be people who use this feature all the time, so for person who uses it all the time, It would be good if you integrate the Windows hello instead of password.
- Even if you integrate the Windows Hello, you should give a choice to opt for Windows Hello or not.
- For something people want to protect , I think they don't look for comfort there. (Though, as I mentioned we might not be using this all the time, and for the person who uses all the time, I'm positive that, one won't feel less convenient)
How should it function?(Of course you know this better than me)
- When we switch to a profile which is opted for password protection, It should prompt for a password or windows hello, then, when we enter the required fields correctly, the profile will switch.
Would you ideally want those passwords to be remembered by the other account? If so, wouldn't that negate any additional security?
- I didn't understand this question properly, but I'll try answering for what I understood, I don't want any account to remember this password( If I think I'll forget, I can save the password and hide it in the computer elsewhere, no one can figure it out)
- The passwords should not be associated with any account (they should be stored in a different location.)
- I don't know whether I answered this question correctly or not.
The picture is a prototype to understand my perspective.( this should happen when I click on my password protected profile)
I hope, I answered your questions correctly and I hope to see this feature in Edge, Thank you 🙂
- dave-voyageJul 12, 2021Copper ContributorThis would be great. Can I just add that these function should be configurable via Group Policy/Intune Policies.
Edge should definitely not remember the password to switch to a new profile.
The way I see this functioning is something like Windows Fast User Switch, but for the browser - DeletedJul 08, 2020
Deleted Thank you for the delightfully detailed feedback and prototype! Adding Avi Vaid, our Profile feature owner, so he can see this too. 🙂
Fawkes (they/them)
Program Manager & Community Manager - Microsoft Edge- manishmaharjanMar 01, 2023Copper Contributor
Is there any update regarding this? This would be very useful especially while working with Work laptop and sharing laptop with friends/family. Since the preferences and passwords are saved on the profile, they would be able to access our contents as well. This is a must have feature.
- DeletedJul 09, 2020
Deleted Good news: the team was intrigued by your detailed feedback, and has started discussing it internally! So while I can't make any guarantees about implementation, I can assure you that the right people have seen this and are looking into it. 🙂
Fawkes (they/them)
Program Manager & Community Manager - Microsoft Edge- F0n1xJul 27, 2022Copper ContributorDo you have any update for this topic?
- alshihiDec 13, 2022Copper Contributoryour suggestion Must be implemented. it is very important for me, and surely for many others