ScottWilbers this behavior may be caused by trying to uninstall Sysmon with the new Sysmon binary, as opposed to the one used for installing.
To manually remove the driver (and service), just delete the autostart keys for the driver and the service, from HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services: Sysmon64 and SysmonDrv. Then reboot (so that the driver stays unloaded) and also delete the binaries from C:\Windows: Sysmon64.exe and SysmonDrv.sys.
The new install will work after this - but go directly to v15.11, it has improvements.