Why „The Next Generation of File & Folder Sharing“ misses the reality of Enterprise Users
A critical perspective from real-world operations in a global company.
Microsoft is rolling out The Next Generation of File & Folder Sharing with the intention of modernizing and simplifying collaboration in SharePoint and OneDrive. While the ambition is understandable, the feature set overlooks a fundamental issue that has existed for years: SharePoint users do not understand the SharePoint permission model — and they do not have the time to learn it.
The core problem:
Ø Users don’t understand permissions, and they never will in their daily workload
Ø In a global enterprise, employees operate under constant pressure. They manage customers, projects, deadlines, compliance requirements, and operational tasks.
Ø What they cannot do is invest time in understanding a complex permission architecture that even experienced administrators need time to navigate.
The result is predictable and happens every single day:
Ø Users break permission inheritance even when it is completely unnecessary.
Ø They share links with people who already have access.
Ø They create redundant or conflicting permissions without realizing it.
Ø They fragment folder structures because they „just need to share something quickly.“
And IT ends up cleaning up the chaos afterwards.
This is not user error.
This is a system design problem.
New sharing features don’t solve the issue — they amplify it.
Every new sharing option adds more complexity:
Ø More choices
Ø More UI elements
Ø More decision points
Ø More potential for misconfiguration
Ø More ways to accidentally break inheritance
Ø More cleanup work for administrators
Users do not want to choose between „specific people“, „organization-wide“, „existing access,“ or „anyone with the link.“
They simply want one thing: Person X should be able to see the file.
The system forces them into decisions they neither understand nor want to make.
The reality in a global company: We restrict what we can — but sharing still spirals out of control
We apply policies.
We restrict external sharing.
We train users.
We document best practices.
And still, every week:
Ø Someone shares a folder with 200 people who already have access.
Ø Someone else breaks inheritance because they think it’s “required.”
Ø Another person creates a link that unintentionally generates a new permission layer.
Ø And the site ends up with a patchwork of unique permissions, limited access entries, and inconsistent inheritance.
This is not a training problem.
It is a design mismatch between the system and the real world.
What is actually needed: fewer options, more clarity, more automation
Instead of adding more sharing features, SharePoint needs:
Ø A radically simplified permission model
Ø Fewer options, fewer decision points, less complexity.
Ø Automatic detection of redundant sharing
Ø „This user already has access. Do you still want to create a new permission?“
Ø Warnings before breaking inheritance
Ø „Breaking inheritance will create complex permissions. Are you sure?“
Ø A clear, visual permission dashboard
Ø No technical jargon. No hidden layers.
Ø A „Safe Sharing Mode“ for end users
Ø Preventing them from unintentionally damaging permission structures.
Conclusion: The new functionality ignores how users actually work
The vision behind The Next Generation of File & Folder Sharing is modern and ambitious.
But it does not address the real issue:
Ø Users do not understand the SharePoint permission model — and they do not have the time to understand it.
Ø As long as the system depends on end users making complex permission decisions, every new sharing feature will increase confusion, not reduce it.
Ø A modern collaboration platform should reduce cognitive load, not increase it.