Blog Post

Exchange Team Blog
2 MIN READ

Future Exchange distribution media: CDs vs. DVD? Let us know!

The_Exchange_Team's avatar
The_Exchange_Team
Platinum Contributor
Mar 04, 2005

Exchange Server 2003 fits on a single CD. For Exchange 12, which is expected to be released in the second half of 2006, the disk space consumption for a full install of the product is much larger than previous versions, because of certain features that use a lot of disk space across multiple languages. So because of that and because we've heard complaints from customers who didn't like multiple-CD installs of other server products, we are evaluating shipping the Exchange12 bits on a single DVD instead of multiple CDs.

 

We're aware that DVD drives are not as common in server hardware as they are in consumer and end user systems, but we're trying to get some feedback to understand how our customers feel about the idea of having a DVD for Exchange instead of multiple CDs. Here are some specific questions that we'd appreciate your answers to:

  • In your Exchange server environment today, do you currently have a DVD drive available - such as on a machine reachable over the network from your server, or a USB DVD drive - from which you can install server software?

  • Thinking about your Exchange environment in late 2006, do you expect to have a DVD drive available from which you can install server software at that time?

  • Would you see Exchange shipping on one DVD (as opposed to multiple CDs) as a convenience or a hassle? If a hassle, do you have a "threshold point" for where a single DVD becomes more attractive than multiple CDs? I.e. is it 3 CDs? 4?

  • Do you have any other comments on DVD or CD media for server software?

Please post your thoughts on this as comments to this post!

 

- KC Lemson

Updated Jul 01, 2019
Version 2.0

68 Comments

  • On one hand practically no (I'm not aware of any) servers from 1st tier vendors (Dell, HPaq, IBM) come from the factory with DVD drives today.

    External USB DVDs are always an option but may be tedious in a datacenter environment, you'd need a kind of "crash cart" to hold your drive while it was hooked up to the server. This is exactly what I've done for blade servers.

    On larger servers you could always swap the CD drive that came with it for a DVD but on the smaller 1U & 2U rackmount server often they have low profile (notebook style) CD drives that are probably harder to get a replacement for. & replacing the optical drive on my brand new server is not something I'd prefer to deal with.

    Of course if media started being available on DVD only that would motivate the hardware manufactuers to include DVD drives with their servers.

    Finally, I suspect that most people copy their installation media to the network and install from a local folder on the server anyways, and practically all notebooks and desktops come with DVD drives so it doesn't matter that much, except maybe in a DR scenario.
  • DVD should be fine. Even if the server doesn't have a DVD a simple share takes care of that.
  • A DVD would be fine, but CD's are OK too. We always copy media off to a file server and I run installs from there.
  • I don't see an issue with sending out DVD's. If you can't afford a $20 DVD drive, you shouldn't be buying exchange.
  • we started procuring servers with DVD drives about a year ago.
  • We currently have DVD drives available on our network as well as a few USB models as well. I wouldn't see that change significantly between now and 2006.

    I think it would be more convenient on the DVD as I often run exchange installs from Network locations anyway.

    As DVD plays continue to proliferate, I think having at least a DVD option would be great.
  • IDEA: is there space on a DVD to store ISO's of the CD's plus the DVD installer?

    then the customer can install from DVD / mount a DVD on a LAN or burn CD's localy if needed.

    that IMHO is the way to do it.

    also I say 1 or 2 CD's are ok, 4+ is a pain.

    and DVD readers are cheap now...
    all new servers I spec a DVD ROM as standard gear.
  • Let DVD rule and make CDs disappear forever.