New updates to Planner comment notifications and settings
Published Jun 25 2018 03:10 PM 186K Views
Microsoft

We’ve received a lot of great feedback on Planner notifications from our users, and over the last few months we’ve rolled out some updates to address this feedback. Here’s more information about the specific changes: 

 

Improvements on who receives task comment email notifications

Previously, whenever a user posted a task comment, a notification was sent to the inbox of all plan members subscribed to the plan’s group. This meant lots of users received comment notifications on tasks not relevant to them. Due to this behavior, a common refrain we’ve heard from customers is “I’ve started using Planner, but these task comment notification emails are too much!” We’ve recently rolled out an update to Planner’s integration with Groups to directly address this.


This update changes the behavior so that users will no longer receive comment notification emails in their inbox for tasks they have never commented on.  Therefore, if you have never commented on a Planner task, and have no plans to comment on it in the future, you should never receive a comment notification in your inbox for said task.


However, when you do post a comment on a task, you will receive email notifications in your inbox for each subsequent comment made on that task (even for comments made by other users). We believe this behavior better scopes the notification audience to those who are most relevant to the task.


Please note that the above behavior only applies to task comments submitted from within the Planner apps. If you choose to “reply all” to the comment notification email (in Outlook or another email client) to add a task comment, all plan members will receive a comment notification email.


You can still check the group mailbox to see the email notifications for every task comment made in a plan.

 

Adding more context to the comment notifications

The email subject line for comment notifications now includes the task name and clearly notes its contents. (Pro tip: you can now construct email rules to route comment notifications to a specific folder since the subject line should always contain the words “comments on task”).


Within the email notification itself, we’ve included the task and plan associated to the comment, as well as deep links for users to directly open the task in Planner to reply. These links are located at the end of the email. (Pro tip: If you choose to reply to the email notification to add a comment, make sure not to reply all if you don’t want your comment to send a notification to all plan members!)

 

This email notification is sent for the first comment on a task.This email notification is sent for the first comment on a task.
This email notification is sent for each reply to a task comment.This email notification is sent for each reply to a task comment.

 

Improved plan notification settings

Our team has updated our notification settings to more cleary define what each options does and makes it easier to configure your notifications.

 

For each plan, opening the “Plan settings” under the “…” menu will show the group email settings for said plan. This is where a group owner can control whether group email notifications are sent when a task is completed or assigned. We’ve also added some information to help guide users to their “group settings” if they want to stop all group email messages from reaching their inbox. Since the options under “group email settings” apply on a per plan basis, a user must visit Plan settings for each plan they are a member of to adjust them. 


Plan settings screenshotPlan settings screenshot

 

We’ve also added a link to “Planner notification settings” inside Plan settings. This link directs the users to where they can adjust their preferences for the types of notifications which are sent to them across all their plans. 

 

Planner notification settings screenshotPlanner notification settings screenshot

 

 

For more information on how our notifications work, please consult our Planner notifications help article.


Let us know what you think about these updates below, and as always please submit ideas for improving Planner through our UserVoice page.

 

83 Comments
Copper Contributor
You know, it may be a bit difficult.. But, an admin setting for "Only send email notifications to assigned users" would be nice. But that would be too logical and we know Microsoft has lost all logic. lol
Copper Contributor
This functionality seems to have been removed. Please update it with more robust comment notification options as many others have noted. The last "solution" was poorly conceived.
Copper Contributor

Adding my concerns to the pile...

 

More Notification options!

 

We are trying to centralize work within Teams, and the fact that Planner App integrated into a channel does not push notifications to teams but instead makes you go to your email, is frustrating.

 

We have work arounds in place but have more options on when and how to be notified would be appreciated!

Copper Contributor

@chtran any news on the implementation of @mention? this would be a great feature. Without this planner is useless.

Even this forum as the functionality built-in.

Copper Contributor

Hello Microsoft,

 

Can you please explain how this is not relevant to "Planner comment notifications and settings"?

Is it beacuse it would be too useful as a feature and you want to be more like Apple (which has an uncanny ability in making things crap)?

Or because you are to embarrased that you overlooked it as a useful feature?

 

I haven't been using teams for very long and am not sure what it used to do but really stuggle to understand the "logic" for deciding to include only people who have previously commented on a task in the email notifications... just crazy really.

 

 

From Deleted, not applicable....

"Can you please, please incorporate a setting that sends email notification updates to all users who are 'assigned' on a task?

 

This would avoid the following scenario that leaves me frequently banging my head against the desk:

 

  • Colleague A assigns Collague B a task in Planner
  • Colleague B receives email notifying them that task has been assigned to them.
  • Colleague A leaves a comment on the task asking for an update from Colleague B
  • Colleague B doesn't receive an email notification because they haven't yet commented on the task, and is not aware that Colleague A needs an update.
  • Colleague A chases up Colleague B by email asking them to look at the task in Planner.

 

Very simple update and easily accounted for I hope..."

Copper Contributor

Got notified today that Planner is changing to Tasks within teams starting in May.

 

You can read it here --> https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/roadmap?filters=&filters=&searchterms=57213

 

We'lls ee if this works better!

Copper Contributor

Is essential that in a task you can notify someone in particular in a comment so you don't fell that you are talking to a board. The same happen with files in comments, referring your comment to a specific file makes clearer what you want and people don't have to guess what you talking about.

Copper Contributor

Thanks for your responsive to community needs. It would help our team to include a little more granularity to the e-mail notification system:

 

  1. Option to disable all group level notifications
  2. Option to send a notification only to those assigned to the task that a new comment or update was made (updates could include notes, dates, bucket, priority, assignees, etc.)
  3. Option to send a notice to those assigned to the task that a comment was added, but to not include the contents of the comment. Some of our comments are detailed, and it's better for our team to keep these in the Tasks instead of distributing them across e-mail.

Thanks again for your help.

Copper Contributor

We have hundreds of users in many of our O365 Groups that are attached to plans in MS Planner.  These members may or may not use the MS Planner piece, yet they get spam email from every comment/action made in MS Planner.

 

Why is there not a way to disable email spam blast to hundreds of members when only a sub group needs to receive them.  Does Microsoft think it is realistic to ask hundreds of users to disable their notification within MS Planner?  They still want emails from conversations, not every single task comment.

 

Strange that Microsoft thinks this is how we want to work off of planner.  Just make a setting to disable comment emails for users not assigned to the task.

Copper Contributor

We have hundreds of members in our O365 Group that is attached to plans in Microsoft Planner. What use case calls for hundreds of emails to be sent out when a simple comment is made on a task. Many O365 Group members are a part of the group for other reasons that to use planner, why do they need to be notified of a task comment?


Strange Microsoft thinks this is a good way to configure notifications. It is not realistic to ask hundreds of users to go into Planner and disable email notifications. Instead...they just get spammed for task comments they know nothing about.

We have stopped using MS Planner enterprise wide until the configuration notification settings are changed.

Copper Contributor

Please give us the option when someone comments in a Task, the whole group in that Task gets a email notification.

Iron Contributor

It has been 2 years and still nothing...

Copper Contributor

Just need a simple option added. "Notify only project members with updates" 

Copper Contributor

teams-planner.jpg

Copper Contributor

Is there any way to get a standard update from Microsoft on the teams/planner notification options? 

Copper Contributor

Has this been updated or changed? 

Copper Contributor

Still a major problem.  When there is a comment on a task, an email notification is sent to the assigned user(s) AND EVERYONE ON THE TEAM.  There is no way to stop that it seems. So if you have 100 people on your team and there are 2 people working on a task that has NOTHING to do with the other 98 people, they get spammed. This causes people to create rules that tuck comment emails into folders, making these comment notifications pointless. 

Copper Contributor

Hello,

 

Has anyone tried to follow the instruction 'You can also reply to this mail to add a task comment'?  

I have and I can't get it to work, plus I don't see how it will work as the mail is sent to me and a distribution group of users that are associated with the task (the team in the case of a planner in being used in Teams), but never to an engine that is going to pick up the planner comment I reply with.

 

ChrisAyers_0-1600685775692.png

Is the option real and my config is broken, or just a figment of a programmer's imagination? 

  

Copper Contributor

Hi all,

I second what ChrisAyers mentioned, and the reason I came here looking for an answer.

We have multiple plan task members, and more often than not, when a member gets an email about a plan task comment or question, they follow the instructions, and simply hit reply in Outlook, which means their reply is NOT captured in the planner task. Awesome recipe for people being misdirected and/or information being lost.

 

Have to ask why bother having those instructions in the email? More to the point, if Microsoft programmers can't get that bit working, would it not be more prudent to simply have the email state "someone has made a comment/added something to a task you are involved in, click here to open the planner task to view the information"? That way it will keep the "paper trail" of information in the one location, which after all is what Microsoft/Office 365, Teams, is all about isn't it?

Copper Contributor

Two things missing! Mentioning someone and receiving comments notifications on Android!

Iron Contributor

I recently moved to Asana because Planner looks like a dead product. It's been going much better.

Copper Contributor

We recently moved to Wrike because Planner was dead.

Copper Contributor

Improvements on who receives task comment email notifications ...

Why don't you allow to configure who need/want to receive the task comment by mail, using for exemple a tag ("balise" in french) with a group of the team members (core team) ?

 

olivier

 

PS : sorry for the quality of my English, I'm a french speaker from Belgium

Copper Contributor

Hi @Charlie Tran 

We have Planner added to a channel in Teams. It is great, BUT, now when we make a comment, they go nowhere, we don't see them in our mail, they don't tack onto the bottom of the task, and they aren't in junk mail. Even when we @ someone nothing... Is there something we should have toggled so someone gets these conversations?  Thanks.

Copper Contributor

@GlobalSway 

 

This is the issue I raised on ‎Sep 21 2020 @03:59 AM

Nobody has answered this yet.

 

 

Copper Contributor

I've read through several comments on the notifications topic. We use Planner regularly, for more and more tasks (Actions, Issues, Decisions, etc.) type items. 


I've found the only way to have more than the assignee notified of any updates is to add multiple "assignees" to the task, is that correct? Then those who are not the "real" assignee get all the "late" or "you have due" notifications, which isn't ideal. 

 

It would be great to be able to: 

- Assign "watchers" to a task - they would get updates on comments or other activity made to the task (attachments, etc), but not get the notication that they have something due or is late. 

 

- another option would be to incorporate the "@mention" to notify non-assignees but interested parties in any activities or comments in the task. (I saw several other comments on that) 

 

- Would be awesome if activity on a planner board that is linked to a TEAM would show up in the activity section of the Teams window as a notification. Then anyone on that planner board and Team could see the notification and check for the update. 

 

 

Brass Contributor

Our tedious workaround is to tell everyone who cares about a Task/Card (creator, assignee(s), watchers) to comment something random in it (like a dot "." or "WIP" or "watching" ) the first time they see it.

 

This makes things look a bit ridiculous & creates some Spam when the task is created, but ensures that the one who just commented will get notified of all future posted comments via email as well (NB: not all future Changes, like to the Title, Description, Checklist, Attachments -- just future Comments).

 

This is because the Comment thread of any Planner Task is an *actual* rendering of a O365 Group Email thread for that Task & every new person to comment gets added to the Senders list from that point on.

 

I.e. the Comment function has been a quick hack all these years & it continues to be ignored.

Iron Contributor


The notification spam seems silly and something that I would prioritize over renaming Planner inside of Teams. Comments are helpful for posting updates to a card and keeping that information in context of the work. Spamming an entire Group of people is distracting and out of context.

Brass Contributor

Microsoft Planner is now used very frequently by our users (via Teams).

However, nearly all of them expect that when a task is created and assigned to certain people, when a new comment is sent, all of these people also receive the information by e-mail.

But at the moment, it is probably the case that even if I am already member of a task, I only receive new comments if I have already written a comment bymyself (subscription method).

It would suggest to have the option in the planner settings to send a mail regarding new comments to all current task participants!

 

Copper Contributor

Yes, quite ridiculous that each member has to make a comment to make sure they get notifications.
I can see the problem from both sides, both for and against. But one would think it could be managed from an administrative area, to either turn it on or off, or more logically, to allow the individual users to opt in and out of each planner task via settings when they don't want constant notifications, if for instance it is an item they physically check every day (not that many people actually check things every day, unless they only have one team, with one planner with one task (ah if life could be that simple eh?). Sort of defeats the whole idea of being a Team, if you are not automatically enrolled to receive notifications, but I do understand the need also to be able to opt out from time to time.

So if you have a large team, with say 400 members, I would choose to be the last to comment, as the first poor bugger to comment is going to cop 399 bland comments of people enrolling to receive comments without any actual important information being passed to anyone.

Awesome right?

Brass Contributor

@mkraemer , @TropicRock & others,

 

As someone actively using 10+ Planners, needless to say I feel your pain. I have fought & failed to get MSoft to do something about it for more than 2 years (I guess I don't have a loud enough voice), so here's what I know:

 

What most people don't know is how the Commenting function was implemented in Planner -- it is not a full-fledged communication function, but rather a quick & dirty thing that uses the Group Email function to fake Comments like we're used to them in Forums (like this one!) -- this is where the spam actually comes from: 

 

The comments at the bottom of each Card are an actual group email thread with the name of the Card -- just go to https://outlook.office365.com/mail/group/<your_company>.onmicrosoft.com/<your_team>/email to check (or via [...] >Plan Settings > Notifications > "Group settings in Outlook"). You will see all Card comments there.

 

Each time Planner loads, it loads the discussion chains from those email threads. That's why:

  1. A person assigned to a Card isn't automatically getting email Notifications - there is no email thread created before that point, and if it is, it's only the Comment poster + the group Email address (whose notifications more & more people are ignoring now by default).
  2. (this should entertain you) You can actually erase history, by going to the Group Email thread & deleting one of your or your colleagues' older Emails (i.e. Comments) -- this will make said Comment magically disappear from Planner next time it loads  👍🏼

 

I tried to suggest to MSoft 2+ years ago that they change the process of assigning a person to a Card to also trigger a Comment/Email from the group email CC-ing the assigned person, so they are, in effect, automatically subscribed for new Comments. Didn't get anywhere.

 

 

Copper Contributor

Ah yes, the problem when you let "smart" people (programmers) who don't actually use a program, (so therefore don't have a clue) control the design of a program. Takes me back to the days of the notorious BSOD, whose messages no doubt made total comprehensible sense to the programmers, but left the normal population, (you know, the people who actually pay for and use the program in everyday working life) with a totally incomprehensible message that told us absolutely nothing.

Good to see they have learnt over the years, and improved their game in programming......................oh, wait ....................no, same shite still ;)

Copper Contributor

@aconstantin 

 

I followed your notes and yes, I can indeed see the comments that have been replied to on a Task.

Thanks for the explanation. 

 

Chris A.

Version history
Last update:
‎Jun 25 2018 03:10 PM
Updated by: