Nov 29 2016 07:49 AM
If I grant a user access to SendAs the O365 Group, and they send an email "as the group", and they don't copy themself, where does that email actually go.
I can't find any record of it anywhere inside the group (only in the inbox of the recipient).
Nov 29 2016 08:04 AM
The Sent folder is hidden and AFAIK you can't access it in any way.
To a Group is actually connected a shared mailbox behind the scenes, but you can't access most of its features.
Hence the overall behavior is similar instead to a DL, with obviously the exception of the conversation space (which behind the scenes is actually the shared mailbox inbox).
Nov 29 2016 08:13 AM
Nov 29 2016 08:19 AM
I don't think that at the moment Groups can be used to replace shared mailboxes: they lack really most of the needed features.
In fact Microsoft is touting them as a replacement for DLs and not for SMs, AFAIK.
Nov 29 2016 09:05 AM
Nov 29 2016 11:00 AM
It's simply what the team has decided, and to be honest I havent heard a single good argument around this. I've given the example with Junk email numerous times, the Sent items is another valid reason why people would actually want access to folders. So is subfolders.
Just avoid using groups as replacement for shared mailbox, there are numerous limitations to such scenario.
Nov 29 2016 10:08 PM
Nov 29 2016 10:17 PM
Nov 29 2016 10:52 PM
I agree that access to the "sent" folder would be appreciated. If we were to replace shared mailboxes (with send as permissions) with O365 groups, we would of course need access to the sent folder (at least), since that message would be essentially lost for the sender without access to it.
Classic scenario would be the office@domainname.com mailbox.
Nov 30 2016 03:02 AM
Also access to Contacts would be very useful...
Anyway, one of the problems with the current implementation, I guess, is that in the Sent folder there are also all the messages sent to the Group itsef from the members, i.e. messages that are surfaced (in the Inbox) as conversations.
The "natural" way to implement conversations would have been, IMHO, connecting from the first moment Groups to Yammer (as will happen in the future - but only optionally). In such a way, a fully functional shared mailbox could have been connected to a Group. But this has not happened...
@cfiessinger, another problem is that MS marketing insists in saying that to every Group is connected a shared mailbox, which is technically true, but not with regard to features. Hence users, reading the marketing blabla, expect to find a fully functional shared mailbox, which unfortunately is not the case...
Just my opinion, of course...
Nov 30 2016 06:13 AM
Nov 30 2016 06:24 AM
Perhaps I have not been clear...
I totally agree with you that ALL the functionalities of the underlying shared mailbox should be exposed in a Group!
Only, I am afraid that this will not happen, because the main purpose of the underlying shared mailbox in the current implementation is to give support to the conversations "space" and this makes difficult (or even impossible) full usage of the shared mailbox.
Nov 30 2016 11:35 AM
Nov 30 2016 01:26 PM
give a look here to my post:
can you give me a short overlook/scenario on HOW you use shared mailbox to collaborate?
AFAIK a shared mailbox is NOT a real collaboration tool !
Bye
Stefano
Nov 30 2016 01:38 PM
Jan 24 2018 06:23 PM
We're trying to solve issues for service centres at our university school that are not handled well by either shared mailboxes or groups, but which would be handled by a better amalgam of the two.
Shared Mailboxes lack
- portability - they require manual setup on all Outlook 2016 clients, and they are not supported at all by mobile clients
- groupware features like file storage and calendars are missing
Groups lack
- automatic SEND AS based on membership
- subfolders, SENT mail in particular
Teams further lack
- UI for external mail inbox (available separately through group UI)
Dec 16 2019 09:33 AM - edited Dec 16 2019 09:34 AM
@Deleted wrote:...
Shared Mailboxes lack
- portability - they require manual setup on all Outlook 2016 clients, and they are not supported at all by mobile clients
- groupware features like file storage and calendars are missing
Groups lack
- automatic SEND AS based on membership
- subfolders, SENT mail in particular
...
@Brent Ellis , almost two years later, has this situation improved at all?
Feb 11 2020 04:52 AM
There exists an add-in for Outlook named BCCtoGroup that BCC every e-mail sent as/on behalf of Office 365 group to that group. It means that any message sent as/on behalf of the group becomes visible for all group members.
Aug 14 2024 05:23 PM - edited Aug 14 2024 05:24 PM
I just set up admin shell for a new business, and boy have things changed...
Main problem I'm looking to solve is the commonly stated issue of having no categorization, outbox, folders, etc in groups. The older shared inbox was far more functional for a multi-person team that monitors a common email alias such as scheduling@, info@, billing@, etc. They need the ability to mark emails as "work-in-progress" or assign a specific team member to respond.
Not sure if shared inbox is still available, but I'm going to look at that next.