Jul 09 2019 07:12 PM - edited Jul 16 2019 12:54 PM
TL;DR: Native text recovery would be an excellent default browser feature (like native pop-up blocking) and shouldn't require extensions.
Ever type a long passage into a browser's text box and then somehow lost the text? Maybe your form got rejected and the site developers wiped the text. Or the site's servers got overloaded with traffic just as you hit "Submit". Or your browser crashed. Or your internet died.
You don't need text box caching...until you need it. A few extensions have been developed purely to solve what I call a genuine browser flaw: save/cache text inside text boxes so it can be restored after an error/crash/bug.
See Lazarus (now defunct), Typio, Textarea Cache, etc. These alone, there's 39k users right there.
Having this feature built-in to Chromium Edge would be a serious quality-of-life improvement for casual and professional users. I'm sure everyone has suffered at least once, but unfortunately not everyone will have had downloaded an extension. I understand being lean, but this feature is so essential, I'm shocked still neither Chrome nor Firefox include this feature natively.
Why it should be integrated natively instead of simply using extensions:
Why this might not be "a love fest of great rejoicing and thankfulness"
Jul 15 2019 04:21 PM
@ikjadoon, this is an interesting problem area. I will send this thread to the sync team, as they have already built a secure channel for saving user content. Thank you for sending it to us. - Elliot
Jul 16 2019 01:31 PM
@Elliot Kirk Oh, that'd be ideal.
For sure: we have "autosave" functionality in Word, PowerPoint, Outlook drafts, these forums etc. I think bringing "Autosave" functionality to the wider web would be an unexpectedly small, but useful addition.
Perhaps if more people are interested!
Oct 19 2019 12:02 PM
@ikjadoon As Chromium Edge inevitably gets closer to launch, giving this thread a bump.
Lost some text yesterday when I accidentally closed a tab and it was sad. :(
Nov 06 2019 12:28 PM
I also want to bump this idea, as I have been badly stung by cleared out text boxes many times! Just to give examples after downloading Edge Insider channels, I've nearly lost multiple Amazon reviews (actually had to fully retype one of them) and this Forum nearly always "finds unacceptable HTML" in my posts for some reason. Even with the draft saving here, I've lost chunks of paragraphs that were somehow improperly formatted. I want to thank the author of the original post for recommending Typio; it might well become one of my favorite extensions. However, I think that a built in textbox history as robust as Google Docs would be extremely beneficial to everyone. Here's my reasons for why, mixed with how I think it should work:
OK at this point I'm just rambling. Hopefully I have made it clear that I'd really love to see this added, even if it can't be any time soon.
Nov 09 2019 08:43 AM
@WolfIcefang Thank you for this detailed post, showcasing exactly why this feature should be natively integrated into Edge.
I hope the Edge team really pushes forward on this & sets the agenda on "minimum browser behavior in the 2020s".
Feb 05 2021 03:01 PM
A friendly bump for native text recovery. If people like this feature request, send a smiley (Alt+Shift+I, "I" as Indigo), drop a comment, or give a thumbs up: it might encourage the Edge team to look at this feature again.
I'm thankful to see the sync team shipping history & tab syncing to the stable branch.
Aug 18 2023 12:32 PM
@ikjadoon This right here, is the reason why I still insist on using the unpacked Lazarus Form Recovery extension in Edge despite is no longer being on the Chrome web store. Every 2 weeks, I get reminded by Edge to disable it, but I just keep postponing the reminder 'cause I simply can't use my browser in peace without it. Countless times, even when typing this post on this very Microsoft Tech Community page, there's been glitches on websites that end up requiring me to refresh the page and risk losing everything I've typed. Fortunately, thanks to Lazarus, I don't worry about such situations anymore, as recovering whatever I've typed is just 2 clicks away.
Of all the other features Microsoft is implementing in Edge, this will be the most useful and endlessly live-saving of them all. Just don't get all stupidly greedy and nosy requiring it to be tied to some skynet account to function. That'll just be a massive red flag of Microsoft disguising a key logger as a feature of Edge.